Gift your home fast internet this holiday. Switch to AT&T Gig for $37/mo.
Home >>
Internet Providers >>
New York >>
Shelter Island Internet
Sponsor Ad
Best Internet providers in Shelter Island, NY
What are the best internet providers in Shelter Island?
The top 10 best Shelter Island internet providers of April 2026 are: Verizon, Optimum and Windstream.
Sponsor Ad
Top rated internet providers for Shelter Island, NY are:
- Verizon - Best fiber internet
- Optimum - Best Value
- Windstream - Best for price
- HughesNet - Best satellite internet provider
Compare Best Home Internet Providers in Shelter Island, NY
#1 Verizon Internet in Shelter Island, NY
Verizon best internet plans for Shelter Island, NY
300 Mbps Internet
$39.99/mo. w/ Auto Pay
- Good Internet speed for stream and download movies, shows and photos.
- Max Internet Speed: 300/300 Mbps
- Disney Bundle for 6 months on us
- Save $10/mo with Unlimited Wireless
500 Mbps Internet
$64.99/mo. w/ Auto Pay
- Good Internet speed for multiple users, streaming and sharing large files.
- Max Internet Speed: 500/500 Mbps
- $100 Verizon Gift Card
- AMC+ for 12 months on us, then $8.99/mo after.
- Save $10/mo with Unlimited Wireless
Gigabit Connection
$89.99/mo. w/ Auto Pay
- Good Internet speed for virtually seamless entertainment experience.
- Max Internet Speed: 940/880 Mbps
- Disney Bundle for 12 months on us
- Save $20/mo with Unlimited Wireless
#2 Optimum Internet in Shelter Island, NY
Optimum best internet plans for Shelter Island, NY
Optimum 100
$35/mo. for 12 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 100/100 Mbps
- Free install
- Internet usage limit: none
Optimum 300
$40/mo. for 12 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 300/300 Mbps
- Free install
- Internet usage limit: none
Optimum 500
$60/mo. for 12 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 500/500 Mbps
- Free install
- Internet usage limit: none
Optimum 1 Gig
$80/mo. for 12 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 940/940 Mbps
- Free install
- Internet usage limit: none
#3 Windstream Internet in Shelter Island, NY
Windstream best internet plans for Shelter Island, NY
Kinetic Internet 200
$39.99/mo. for 12 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 200 Mbps
- Internet usage limit: none
- 30 Day Money-Back Guarantee
Kinetic Internet 400
$59.99/mo. for 12 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 400 Mbps
- Internet usage limit: none
- 30 Day Money-Back Guarantee
Kinetic Internet 500
$57/mo. for 12 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 500 Mbps
- Internet usage limit: none
- 30 Day Money-Back Guarantee
Kinetic Gig Internet
$69.99/mo. for 3 mos.
- Max Internet Speed: 1,000 Mbps
- Internet usage limit: none
- 30 Day Money-Back Guarantee
Shelter Island Top Zip Codes
| Zip Code | Population |
|---|---|
| 11964 | 1,858 |